Voluntary Departure After Matter of Ontiveros-Diaz: Miss the Deadline and a 10-Year Bar Follows
On November 5, 2026, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) ruled in Matter of Ontiveros-Diaz that a person who stays past a voluntary departure deadline is barred for 10 years from cancellation of removal, adjustment of status and other relief, and that a motion to reopen filed after the deadline doesn’t undo that bar, even when it only adds evidence to an earlier application.
INA 240B(d)(1), 8 U.S.C. 1229c(d)(1)
An alien who “voluntarily fails to depart the United States within the time period specified” shall be ineligible, for 10 years, “to receive any further relief” under the listed sections.
Key takeaways
- Matter of Ontiveros-Diaz, 30 I&N Dec. 222 (BIA 2026), is a published precedent: missing a voluntary departure deadline triggers a 10-year bar on cancellation of removal, adjustment of status, change of status, registry and voluntary departure.
- A motion to reopen filed after the departure deadline doesn’t erase the bar, even if it only adds new evidence to an application that was already pending.
- A motion to reopen or reconsider, or a petition for review, filed before the deadline ends the voluntary departure grant and the statutory penalties don’t apply.
- Voluntary departure periods are short: up to 120 days before proceedings end and up to 60 days at the end, while a motion to reopen can be filed for 90 days. That gap is where this case was lost.
- EOIR data show 72,761 voluntary departure or withdrawal outcomes in FY2026 through July, 11.3% of initial removal-case decisions.
What did the BIA decide in Matter of Ontiveros-Diaz?
The Board issued two holdings. First, “a violation of a voluntary departure agreement renders an alien ineligible for certain immigration benefits for a 10-year period.” Second, filing a motion to reopen to submit new evidence on an earlier cancellation application “does not relieve an alien of the consequences of failing to voluntarily depart.”
The respondent argued that the bar was “simply irrelevant” because he wasn’t asking for new relief, and that reopening would mean there was no longer a final order. The Board rejected both points. It called a voluntary departure order an agreement: the person promises to leave, and the government agrees not to enter a removal order if they do. It relied on 8 CFR 1240.26(e)(2), which says that granting a late motion to reopen “does not have the effect of vitiating or vacating” penalties that have already taken effect, and on the 2008 rule that adopted that text (73 FR 76927).
The conduct that triggers the bar is the missed deadline. Reopening the case later doesn’t change that the deadline was missed.
As an alternative ground, the Board found the new evidence (a new school plan for one child, an autism diagnosis for another, PTSD records for a third) similar to evidence already considered, so it was unlikely to change the finding that the U.S. citizen children wouldn’t suffer “exceptional and extremely unusual hardship.” The motion was denied on both grounds.
How did the voluntary departure deadline play out in this case?
The dates come from the decision itself. They show how a filing can be on time for one deadline and late for another.
- April 4, 2025The BIA dismisses the appeal from the denial of cancellation of removal and reinstates the judge’s 60-day departure period.
- June 3, 2025The departure deadline passes. The respondent hasn’t left and hasn’t filed anything.
- June 17, 2025He files a motion to reopen with new hardship evidence: 14 days after the departure deadline, but inside the 90-day motion window under INA 240(c)(7)(C)(i).
- November 5, 2026The BIA denies the motion in a published decision binding on immigration judges nationwide.
Our arithmetic: a 60-day departure period that starts on the same day as the 90-day motion window leaves 30 days in which a motion is still timely as a motion but comes too late to avoid the penalties. Filing inside the first 60 days would have ended the grant without triggering the bar, under 8 CFR 1240.26(e)(1). The decision notes he didn’t claim his failure to leave was involuntary, the exception recognized in Matter of Zmijewska (2007) for people who, through no fault of their own, didn’t know of the order or couldn’t physically leave.
What is voluntary departure, and how do the two kinds differ?
Voluntary departure is permission to leave the United States at your own expense by a set date instead of being ordered removed. Every grant comes with an alternate order of removal that takes effect if the conditions aren’t met (8 CFR 1240.26(d)). The statute, INA 240B, creates two versions.
| Point | Before proceedings end (240B(a)) | At the end of proceedings (240B(b)) |
|---|---|---|
| Maximum period | 120 days | 60 days |
| When to ask | At or before the master calendar hearing that sets the merits hearing (or by DHS stipulation) | At the end of the merits hearing |
| Main conditions | Concede removability, withdraw other relief requests, waive appeal; no aggravated felony conviction and not deportable on security grounds | 1 year of physical presence before the Notice to Appear, 5 years of good moral character, means and intent to leave shown by clear and convincing evidence, a valid travel document |
| Bond | Optional, at the judge’s discretion | Required: at least $500, posted with ICE within 5 business days |
| Appeal | Waived | Allowed; proof of bond due to the BIA within 30 days of the appeal |
Only DHS can extend the time to leave, and never beyond the 120-day or 60-day limit (8 CFR 1240.26(f)). Someone previously allowed to depart after being found present without admission under INA 212(a)(6)(A) can’t receive it again (INA 240B(c)). The same 10-year bar also covers departure granted by DHS before any court case, according to 8 CFR 1240.26(a).
What does failing to depart on time cost?
Under INA 240B(d) and 8 CFR 1240.26, a person who voluntarily fails to leave on time faces three consequences.
A civil penalty of $1,000 to $5,000
The regulation presumes $3,000 unless the judge or the Board sets a different amount when granting voluntary departure (8 CFR 1240.26(l)).
A 10-year bar on five forms of relief
| INA section | Relief barred for 10 years |
|---|---|
| 240B | Voluntary departure |
| 240A | Cancellation of removal (permanent and nonpermanent residents) |
| 245 | Adjustment of status to permanent residence |
| 248 | Change of nonimmigrant status |
| 249 | Registry |
The statute has one carve-out: the bar doesn’t apply to cancellation or adjustment based on a VAWA self-petition if extreme cruelty or battery was at least one central reason for the overstay (INA 240B(d)(2)). The list doesn’t name asylum, withholding of removal or protection under the Convention Against Torture. Whether other rules limit those claims depends on the case.
A removal order and its own reentry bar
When the grant fails, the alternate removal order takes effect. A person who later leaves while that order is outstanding is inadmissible for 10 years under INA 212(a)(9)(A)(ii) unless DHS consents to reapplication (Form I-212). That is separate from the unlawful presence bars explained in our guide to when unlawful presence triggers the 3-year or 10-year bar. The decision’s closing notice also points to a civil penalty of up to $998 a day for willfully failing to leave under a final removal order (INA 274D).
Which timing choices trigger the voluntary departure penalties?
The outcome turns on what happens before the deadline. This matrix sets out what the regulation says for common situations; the details of any one case can change the answer.
| Situation | Voluntary departure grant | Alternate removal order | Fine and 10-year bar |
|---|---|---|---|
| Leaves by the deadline and proves departure | Fulfilled | Not in effect | No |
| Files a motion to reopen or reconsider before the deadline (8 CFR 1240.26(e)(1)) | Ends | Takes effect | No |
| Files a petition for review in federal court before leaving (8 CFR 1240.26(i)) | Ends | Takes effect | No |
| Stays past the deadline, then files a motion to reopen (Ontiveros-Diaz) | Violated | Takes effect | Yes |
| Stays past the deadline because of battery or extreme cruelty, then seeks VAWA-based relief (INA 240B(d)(2)) | Violated | Takes effect | Bar lifted for that relief |
| Didn’t know of the order or was physically unable to leave, through no fault of their own (Matter of Zmijewska) | Not a voluntary failure | Case-specific | No |
Green: no penalty. Amber: depends on facts or a limited exception. Red: penalty or removal order applies.
Two details matter. A person granted departure at the end of proceedings who files a petition for review isn’t treated as removed if they leave within 30 days of filing and prove it to DHS (8 CFR 1240.26(i)). And the 30-day deadline for a petition for review under INA 242(b)(1) falls inside a 60-day departure period.
How common is voluntary departure, and why do motions matter now?
EOIR’s FY2026 decision-outcome table, generated July 24, 2026, counts 641,503 initial decisions in removal, deportation and exclusion cases. EOIR reports voluntary departure together with withdrawal of an application for admission.
Motions to reopen have also surged. Immigration courts received 54,557 in FY2025, about four times the 13,720 of FY2016 and 3.4 times the FY2022 level. Each of those filings is a point where the timing rules above decide whether the penalties attach.
| Fiscal year | Immigration court motions to reopen | BIA motions (reopen, reconsider, recalendar) |
|---|---|---|
| 2016 | 13,720 | 5,641 |
| 2017 | 15,896 | 5,898 |
| 2018 | 17,760 | 7,658 |
| 2019 | 20,147 | 5,568 |
| 2020 | 17,887 | 4,993 |
| 2021 | 10,877 | 5,784 |
| 2022 | 16,265 | 4,522 |
| 2023 | 29,203 | 5,097 |
| 2024 | 44,662 | 7,197 |
| 2025 | 54,557 | 7,643 |
| 2026 (through Q3) | 28,437 | 4,600 |
Method: shares and ratios computed from EOIR’s published counts. EOIR statistics are drawn from a live database and are subject to change. FY2026 figures are partial-year.
Edge cases and open questions
- Failure to post bond. Not posting the bond doesn’t cancel the duty to leave or the penalties. If appeal was waived, the removal order takes effect at once, but a person granted departure at the end of proceedings isn’t treated as removed if they leave within 25 days and prove it (8 CFR 1240.26(c)(4)).
- No judicial review of a denial. Courts can’t hear an appeal from the denial of a departure request at the end of proceedings, or stay removal over it (INA 240B(f)).
- Federal courts. Ontiveros-Diaz binds immigration judges and the Board. It is consistent with Taveras-Duran v. Holder (1st Cir. 2014), which the Board cited. Whether any circuit court will read the statute differently hasn’t been tested since this decision.
- Related appeal rules. The BIA’s new appeal procedures take effect December 17, 2026; see our summary of the BIA appeals final rule.
What to do now if you have a voluntary departure order
- Find the exact departure date on the order and count it against the 30-day petition-for-review and 90-day motion deadlines.
- Check whether a bond was required and whether it was posted within 5 business days (or 30 business days after a BIA grant).
- If you are considering a motion or a petition for review, have an attorney review it well before the departure date, not after.
- If you plan to leave, keep proof of departure for ICE and for the bond refund.
- If illness, detention or a lack of travel documents could prevent departure, raise it early and keep records.
These are general steps, not advice for a specific case.
Frequently asked questions
What did the BIA decide in Matter of Ontiveros-Diaz?
On November 5, 2026, the Board held that violating a voluntary departure agreement makes a person ineligible for certain immigration benefits for 10 years, and that a motion to reopen filed after the departure deadline to add new evidence to an earlier cancellation application doesn’t remove that bar. The motion was also denied because the new evidence was unlikely to change the result.
Which relief does the 10-year voluntary departure bar block?
INA 240B(d)(1)(B) bars relief under sections 240B, 240A, 245, 248 and 249: voluntary departure, cancellation of removal, adjustment of status, change of nonimmigrant status and registry. A VAWA-based exception applies to cancellation and adjustment when abuse was at least one central reason for the overstay. The list doesn’t name asylum, withholding or Convention Against Torture protection.
Can a motion to reopen avoid the voluntary departure penalties?
Only if it is filed before the departure deadline. Under 8 CFR 1240.26(e)(1), a motion to reopen or reconsider filed during the departure period automatically ends the grant, the alternate removal order takes effect, and the statutory penalties don’t apply. A motion filed after the deadline leaves the penalties in place, as Ontiveros-Diaz confirms.
How much is the fine for failing to depart?
The statute sets a civil penalty of $1,000 to $5,000. Under 8 CFR 1240.26(l), the amount is presumed to be $3,000 unless the immigration judge or the Board sets a higher or lower amount when granting voluntary departure, and the person must be told the amount at that time.
How long does voluntary departure last?
Up to 120 days if granted before removal proceedings end, and up to 60 days if granted at the end of proceedings. Only DHS can extend the period, and never past those limits. Filing a motion to reopen or reconsider doesn’t pause or extend it, according to 8 CFR 1240.26(f).
What happens if I file a petition for review in federal court?
Filing a petition for review ends the voluntary departure grant and the alternate removal order takes effect, but the 240B(d) penalties don’t apply while the petition is pending. A person granted voluntary departure at the end of proceedings who leaves within 30 days of filing, and proves it to DHS, isn’t treated as removed.
Facing a voluntary departure deadline?
We can review the order, the bond and the deadlines for motions and petitions for review, and explain the options that remain open.
Start your free evaluationSources
- Matter of Ontiveros-Diaz, 30 I&N Dec. 222 (BIA 2026), Interim Decision #4272 (decided Nov. 5, 2026)
- EOIR, AG/BIA Precedent Decisions, Volume 30
- 8 U.S.C. 1229c (INA 240B), Voluntary departure
- 8 CFR 1240.26, Voluntary departure — authority of EOIR (eCFR)
- Voluntary Departure: Effect of a Motion to Reopen or Reconsider or a Petition for Review, 73 FR 76927 (Dec. 18, 2008)
- 8 U.S.C. 1182(a)(9)(A) (INA 212(a)(9)(A)), Aliens previously removed
- 8 U.S.C. 1252(b)(1) (INA 242(b)(1)), Petition for review deadline
- EOIR Adjudication Statistics, FY 2026 Decision Outcomes (data generated July 24, 2026)
- EOIR Adjudication Statistics, Motions (data generated July 24, 2026)
This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Immigration law changes often and every case depends on its facts. Speak with a licensed immigration attorney about your situation. This summary reflects the BIA decision, the statute, the regulations and EOIR data as of November 20, 2026. Attorney Advertising.