News & Insights

The Supreme Court Will Decide the Southern Border Asylum Ban: What Mullin v. RAICES Means Now

By Clarvo Legal · November 18, 2026

The Supreme Court agreed on November 13, 2026 to decide whether the southern border asylum ban in Proclamation 10888 is lawful. Here is what the Court will decide, which rules apply at the border today, and what CBP's own data show.

Immigration News · Asylum and the border

The Supreme Court Will Decide the Southern Border Asylum Ban: What Mullin v. RAICES Means Now

On November 13, 2026, the Supreme Court agreed to decide whether the southern border asylum ban in Proclamation 10888 is lawful. Until the Court rules, the ban on applying for asylum after crossing the southern border stays in effect under an appeals-court stay, while the lower courts’ rulings protecting withholding of removal and torture claims remain in force.

Key takeaways

  • The Supreme Court granted review in Mullin v. Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services (No. 26-239) on November 13, 2026, limited to two questions.
  • It will decide whether Proclamation 10888 and DHS’s guidance lawfully cut off access to asylum and other protection, and whether federal law bars the classwide injunction.
  • The D.C. Circuit ruled the asylum ban unlawful in April 2026, but its mandate is on hold, so the asylum restriction keeps operating until the Supreme Court decides.
  • CBP data show southwest border encounters fell from 2.14 million in FY2024 to 139,983 in FY2026, a 93% drop. The two sides read that drop differently.
  • No argument date has been set. Anyone with a pending or possible protection claim should get individual advice now rather than wait for the ruling.

What did the Supreme Court agree to decide?

The Court’s docket entry for November 13, 2026 reads that the petition was “GRANTED limited to Questions 1 and 2.” The government, led by Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin, filed the petition on August 24, 2026 after losing in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit.

1Is the proclamation lawful?

Whether Proclamation No. 10888 and its implementing guidance, which suspended the entry of certain people and blocked their access to INA provisions that would let them stay, including asylum, are lawful.

2Can courts block it classwide?

Whether 8 U.S.C. 1252(f)(1), which limits lower courts’ power to “enjoin or restrain” parts of the removal statute, bars the classwide injunction the district court entered.

Not taken: Question 3, whether the certified class satisfies Article III and Rule 23. The class definition approved by the D.C. Circuit stays as it is for this appeal.

A Presidential Proclamation under INA 212(f) is an order in which the President suspends or restricts the entry of a class of noncitizens he finds “detrimental to the interests of the United States.” The Supreme Court upheld a 212(f) travel ban in Trump v. Hawaii (2018). This case asks a different question: whether an entry suspension can also shut off the asylum process for people who are already on U.S. soil.

What does the asylum ban in Proclamation 10888 do?

President Trump signed Proclamation 10888, “Guaranteeing the States Protection Against Invasion,” on January 20, 2025 (90 FR 8333). Read from its text:

SectionWhat it says
Sec. 1Suspends entry of people “engaged in the invasion across the southern border” until the President finds the invasion has ceased.
Sec. 2Restricts those people from invoking INA provisions that would allow them to remain, “including, but not limited to,” the asylum statute (INA 208).
Sec. 3Applies the same suspension and restriction to anyone who fails, before entering, to give officials enough medical, criminal history and background information to apply the health, criminal and security grounds of inadmissibility.
Sec. 4Invokes Article II and Article IV, Section 4 of the Constitution to suspend “physical entry.”
Sec. 5Directs DHS, with State and Justice, to “repel, repatriate, or remove” covered people.

DHS carried out the proclamation through internal guidance. According to the government’s petition, that guidance tells agents that covered people may not apply for asylum and aren’t eligible for statutory withholding of removal. Fear of torture claims under the Convention Against Torture (CAT) go through streamlined screening, and unaccompanied children aren’t covered. The challengers argue that the screening requirements effectively made CAT protection unavailable for many people.

What rules apply at the border right now?

The answer comes from two orders. The district court ruled for the challengers on July 2, 2025. On August 1, 2025, a D.C. Circuit panel stayed only part of that judgment. The appeals court later ruled against the government on the merits, but it has held back its mandate while the case is in the Supreme Court. The August 2025 split is therefore still the working rule:

The statutory path (INA)

  1. Person is encountered after crossing.
  2. Expedited removal under 8 U.S.C. 1225(b) or regular removal proceedings under 1229a.
  3. A fear claim leads to a credible fear screening.
  4. Asylum, withholding of removal and CAT can be heard by an asylum officer or immigration judge.

The proclamation path

  1. Person is covered by Sec. 1–3 of the proclamation.
  2. Asylum application not accepted. Operating
  3. Withholding of removal barred. Blocked
  4. Removal by non-statutory “repatriation.” Blocked
  5. New CAT screening steps. Blocked

“Operating” means the D.C. Circuit stayed the lower court’s ruling on this point. “Blocked” means the district court’s ruling against it was not stayed. This summary is based on the government’s petition and the respondents’ brief, and practice at the border can vary. It isn’t a description of any individual case.

How did the case reach the Supreme Court?

  1. Jan. 20, 2025. Proclamation 10888 signed (published Jan. 29).
  2. Feb. 3, 2025. Three nonprofit organizations and 13 individuals sue in federal district court in Washington, D.C. (RAICES v. Noem, No. 25-306).
  3. July 2, 2025. The district court certifies a class, holds the proclamation and guidance unlawful, and enters a classwide injunction.
  4. Aug. 1, 2025. The D.C. Circuit stays the ruling on asylum only. Withholding, CAT and the repatriation process stay blocked.
  5. Apr. 24, 2026. A different D.C. Circuit panel affirms in a divided opinion (174 F.4th 81), holding the asylum restrictions unlawful too.
  6. July 23–27, 2026. Rehearing en banc denied. The mandate is stayed pending Supreme Court review.
  7. Aug. 24, 2026. The government files its petition for certiorari.
  8. Nov. 13, 2026. Certiorari granted on Questions 1 and 2.

What does each side argue?

IssueThe government (petitioners)The challengers (respondents)
AsylumAsylum is discretionary. The President has already decided that covered applicants would be denied, so the government needn’t accept “futile” applications.The INA lets anyone physically present apply. Categorical bars must be created “by regulation” and be consistent with the statute (8 U.S.C. 1158(b)(2)(C)).
212(f) powerThe power to exclude includes setting conditions for removing people who violate an entry suspension.Section 212(f) speaks to “entry,” not removal of people already here, and the D.C. Circuit agreed.
Withholding and CATDefended in the lower courts.Say the government no longer defends eliminating withholding or restricting CAT, which every judge below held unlawful.
Classwide relief8 U.S.C. 1252(f)(1) bars lower courts from enjoining removal provisions classwide.The injunction doesn’t mandate removals. It only requires removals to follow the statute.
Border conditionsEncounters fell 93% after the proclamation, and the asylum restrictions have been “critical” to that.Apprehensions had already returned to routine levels before the proclamation took effect.

What does the border data actually show?

Both briefs make claims about border numbers, so we checked them against CBP’s own monthly file of southwest land border encounters. An encounter is any Border Patrol apprehension between ports of entry, or any Office of Field Operations finding of inadmissibility at a port of entry.

2,135,005encounters, FY2024
443,671encounters, FY2025
139,983encounters, FY2026
Before the proclamation (Oct. 2023 – Jan. 2025)After (Feb. 2025 – Sept. 2026)
Monthly southwest land border encounters, all CBP components. Source: CBP Southwest Land Border Encounters data file (FY2023–FY2026), accessed November 18, 2026. January 2025 includes days before and after January 20.
Measure (CBP data)Value
Peak month in the period: December 2023301,981
January 2025 (proclamation signed Jan. 20)61,445
February 2025, first full month after11,710
FY2026 monthly range9,613 – 13,544
Change, FY2024 to FY2026−93.4%
Border Patrol only: Dec. 2023 → Jan. 2025249,740 → 29,105 (−88.3%)
Border Patrol only: Jan. 2025 → Feb. 202529,105 → 8,349 (−71.3%)

The data support part of each side’s story. Border Patrol encounters had already fallen 88% from their December 2023 peak by January 2025, which is consistent with the challengers’ point. They then fell another 71% in the first full month after the proclamation and have stayed near that level for 19 months, which is the drop the government relies on. The data can’t isolate how much of the later drop came from the asylum restriction itself rather than other measures that took effect at the same time. That is a judgment the briefs, not the numbers, make.

Method: monthly totals summed across all components, demographics and titles of authority in CBP’s published CSV. Percent change = (later − earlier) ÷ earlier. The government’s petition also cites its own declaration for two further figures: credible fear referrals rose from 21% of encounters in 2014 to 49% in 2024, and 17% of completed cases were granted relief. We report those as the government’s figures because the underlying dataset isn’t in the public record we reviewed.

Who is affected, and who isn’t?

Directly affected

People who cross the southern border on or after January 20, 2025 and fall within Sections 1–3. The class certified in the case covers people present in the United States while the proclamation is in effect who would seek asylum, withholding of removal or CAT protection but for the proclamation, and who aren’t statutorily ineligible for all of those forms of relief.

Disputed edge

The government describes the policy as aimed at people crossing between ports of entry. The challengers say Section 3’s information requirement reaches people who present at a port of entry too. The Supreme Court’s ruling on Question 1 may clarify how far the proclamation reaches.

Not addressed by the proclamation

The proclamation is written around entries across the southern border. It doesn’t, by its terms, change the rules for people who entered another way and apply for asylum affirmatively with USCIS, although other 2026 changes do affect those cases (see our post on what changed for pending asylum cases). Unaccompanied children are excluded under DHS’s guidance, according to the government.

What happens next, and what can you do now?

The parties will file merits briefs, and the Court will schedule oral argument. No argument date was listed on the docket as of November 18, 2026. The Court could uphold the proclamation, affirm the D.C. Circuit, or decide the case on the narrower Question 2. A ruling only on Question 2 could leave the legal holdings in place but limit how far the relief reaches beyond the named plaintiffs.

  1. Keep evidence of entry date and place. Whether and how the proclamation applies can turn on when and where someone entered.
  2. Don’t give up a protection claim. Withholding of removal and CAT protection aren’t currently cut off by the proclamation under the court orders in effect. Our guides to credible fear screening and asylum bars explain how those claims work.
  3. Watch filing deadlines. Deadlines for applications and appeals keep running regardless of the Supreme Court case.
  4. Get advice on your own facts. Families with relatives at or near the border, and people already in proceedings, should talk to an immigration attorney about how the current orders apply to them.

Frequently asked questions

Is the southern border asylum ban in effect right now?

Yes, the asylum part is. The D.C. Circuit held it unlawful in April 2026 but stayed its mandate while the Supreme Court reviews the case. Under an August 2025 partial stay, the restriction on applying for asylum keeps operating, while the lower court’s rulings on withholding of removal, CAT protection and non-statutory repatriation remain in force.

What is Mullin v. RAICES about?

It is the government’s appeal of rulings that Proclamation 10888 and DHS guidance unlawfully blocked access to asylum and other protection for people crossing the southern border. The Supreme Court agreed on November 13, 2026 to decide whether the policy is lawful and whether 8 U.S.C. 1252(f)(1) bars the classwide injunction.

When will the Supreme Court decide?

No date is set. As of November 18, 2026, the docket showed the grant but no argument date. Merits briefing comes first, then oral argument, and the Court issues its opinion afterward. Until then the current court orders control how the proclamation is applied.

Can people covered by the proclamation still seek protection?

Under the orders now in effect, the bar on applying for asylum operates, but the lower court’s rulings protecting withholding of removal and the regular CAT procedures were not stayed. How that plays out for one person depends on where and when they entered and what happened at the border, so individual advice matters.

Does the proclamation affect people who entered with a visa?

The proclamation is written around entries across the southern border on or after January 20, 2025. It doesn’t, by its terms, address people who entered another way and apply affirmatively with USCIS. Other 2026 policy changes may still affect those applicants, so check your own case with an attorney.

Why did border encounters drop so sharply?

CBP data show southwest border encounters fell from 2,135,005 in FY2024 to 139,983 in FY2026. Border Patrol encounters had already fallen 88% from their December 2023 peak by January 2025, then fell another 71% in February 2025. The data alone can’t separate the effect of the asylum restriction from other measures.

Need to understand where your family’s case stands?

We can review entry dates, prior filings and the court orders now in effect, and explain which protection options remain open.

Start your free evaluation

Sources

  1. Supreme Court of the United States, Docket No. 26-239, Mullin v. Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services (cert. granted Nov. 13, 2026)
  2. Questions presented, No. 26-239
  3. Petition for a writ of certiorari (Aug. 24, 2026)
  4. Brief in opposition (Sept. 23, 2026)
  5. Proclamation 10888, Guaranteeing the States Protection Against Invasion, 90 FR 8333 (Jan. 29, 2025)
  6. U.S. Customs and Border Protection, Southwest Land Border Encounters (data file FY2023–FY2026)

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Immigration law changes often and every case depends on its facts. Speak with a licensed immigration attorney about your situation. This summary reflects the Supreme Court docket, the parties’ filings, the Federal Register and CBP data as of November 18, 2026. Attorney Advertising.

01

Related Visa Category

02

Related Articles

03

More Articles

Need help with your immigration case?

Speak with our team about your options and the right next steps for your situation.

Book a ConsultationContact Us

← Back to all articles

Need help with your immigration case?

Hasan Legal PC attorneys handle USCIS petitions, family immigration, employment-based green cards, and naturalization across Washington DC, Virginia and Maryland.

Book a Consultation Free Evaluation
For informational purposes only — not legal advice · Consult an attorney for your specific situation.