News & Insights

USCIS Proposes Ending Deference on Extension Petitions: What It Means for H-1B, L-1 and O-1 Renewals

By Clarvo Legal · November 16, 2026

DHS wants to remove the rule that tells USCIS officers to defer to a prior approval when an employer extends a worker’s petition. Here is what the USCIS deference policy does today, what DHS’s own data says about RFEs, and how to build an extension that stands on its own.

Immigration News · Proposed rule

USCIS Proposes Ending Deference on Extension Petitions: What It Means for H-1B, L-1 and O-1 Renewals

DHS has proposed repealing the USCIS deference policy for work-visa extensions. Today, when an employer files Form I-129 to extend a worker’s petition with the same parties and facts, officers start from the earlier approval. The October 14, 2026 proposal would remove that starting point, so every extension must prove eligibility again. It isn’t final yet.

8 CFR 214.1(c)(5), as DHS describes it

When adjudicating a Form I-129 involving the same parties and the same underlying facts, USCIS gives deference to its prior determination of eligibility, unless there is a material error, a material change, or new material information that adversely impacts eligibility.
Proposed: remove this paragraph entirely

Wording from the proposed rule’s description of the current regulation, 91 FR 65119, 65121–65122.

Key takeaways

  • A proposed rule published October 14, 2026 would remove 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5), the regulation telling USCIS to defer to prior I-129 approvals with the same parties and facts.
  • It is not final: deference still applies today, and comments are open through November 13, 2026.
  • About 208,429 extension petitions a year were eligible for deference in FY2022–FY2025, 30% of all Form I-129 filings.
  • DHS estimates about 6,044 more RFEs a year but found no change in denial rates when deference was last switched off.

What is the USCIS deference policy?

The USCIS deference policy is a rule of review: when an employer asks to extend a nonimmigrant worker’s petition and nothing material has changed, the officer generally accepts the earlier finding of eligibility rather than re-deciding it. It applies to Form I-129, the petition used for H-1B, L-1, O-1, E, TN, P, R and other worker categories.

Deference was never automatic approval. An officer can depart from the earlier approval if there was a material error, a material change in circumstances, or new material information that hurts eligibility. Under the USCIS Policy Manual, Vol. 2, Part A, Ch. 4, an officer who declines to defer must acknowledge the prior approval in the Request for Evidence (RFE), Notice of Intent to Deny (NOID) or denial, explain why, and give the petitioner a chance to respond.

What would the proposed rule change?

The notice of proposed rulemaking would delete 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5) for all Form I-129 benefit requests. Officers could still look at a prior approval “where relevant”, but they would no longer start from the position that it was right.

DHS gives three reasons. First, the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) section 291 puts the burden of proof on the petitioner, and DHS believes deference shifts it to the officer in practice. Second, it says deference discourages officers from fully exploring the facts. Third, it argues that deference can carry forward approvals that were wrong or fraudulent.

DHS considered rewording the rule to say USCIS “may” give deference, and rejected it as likely to create “unnecessary confusion and uncertainty.”91 FR 65119, 65125

On reliance, DHS says employers and workers have limited interests at stake because deference never assured approval and removing it doesn’t change who is eligible.

How has deference swung since 2004?

If it becomes final, this would be the third reversal since 2004. Each change shifted how extension petitions were reviewed:

DateActionDeference?
Apr. 23, 2004USCIS memo HQPRD 72/11.3 tells officers to defer to prior approvals on extensionsOn
Oct. 23, 2017PM-602-0151 rescinds the 2004 memo, citing burden-shiftingOff
Apr. 2021USCIS reinstates deference in the Policy ManualOn
Dec. 18, 2024H-1B Modernization final rule writes it into 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5) (89 FR 103054)On (regulation)
Oct. 14, 2026NPRM proposes removing the regulation (91 FR 65119)Proposed off
Source: 91 FR 65119, Sec. II.D and IV.A.

How many petitions does the USCIS deference policy touch?

DHS pulled 12 years of USCIS data. From FY2014 through FY2025, 2,168,394 of 7,206,852 Form I-129 petitions, or 30%, were the kind of extension where deference usually applies. That count rose from 139,028 in FY2014 to 235,583 in FY2025, up 69.5% by our arithmetic.

Form I-129 petitions eligible for deference, by fiscal year. FY2021 is shown as “not in effect” because deference returned partway through the year. Full numbers are in the table below.
Fiscal yearAll I-129 petitionsEligible for deferenceShare
2014453,649139,02831%
2015508,706144,83628%
2016564,134142,54825%
2017561,593158,90228%
2018583,469163,88428%
2019619,139185,70030%
2020590,357209,70536%
2021570,486190,07633%
2022713,773195,54727%
2023643,214194,31430%
2024683,522208,27130%
2025714,810235,58333%
Source: 91 FR 65119, Table 2 (USCIS CDAO data queried May 2026). DHS counts petitions marked as continuing or changing previously approved employment with the same employer, and notes amended petitions may add a few more.

What happened to RFEs and denials when deference was off?

DHS tested the 2017–2021 period, when deference was switched off, against the 2013–2017 period, when it was on. It compared extension petitions with other I-129 petitions (new employment, new concurrent employment and change of employer) to filter out broader trends.

RFE rateDeference on
Oct. 2013–Oct. 2017
Deference off
Oct. 2017–Apr. 2021
Change
Extensions (affected)18.9%23.4%+4.5 pts
Other I-129s (comparison)31.4%33.0%+1.6 pts
Difference attributed to deference+2.9 pts
Source: 91 FR 65119, Table 3. Underlying counts: 111,561 RFEs on 589,272 extensions (deference on) and 152,856 RFEs on 653,142 extensions (deference off).

Three points follow from DHS’s own numbers:

  • RFEs on extensions rose about a quarter. Going from 18.9% to 23.4% is a 23.8% relative increase (our arithmetic), though DHS attributes only 2.9 points of it to deference.
  • Denials didn’t move. DHS ran the same test on denial rates and “found no corresponding change.” The likely cost is time and paperwork, not outcomes, based on the past.
  • DHS’s cost figure is small by design. It projects about 6,044 extra RFEs a year (208,429 × 2.9%) and $133,987 a year in total, or $22.17 per RFE. That figure assumes 10 minutes to respond to an RFE, a burden estimate carried over from the 2024 modernization rule. Real responses to extension RFEs often involve collecting new records, so the time is likely to vary widely.

Would the proposal affect your extension?

Answer three questions to see how the current rule and the proposal treat your filing.

Question 1

Is the filing a Form I-129 petition?

H-1B, L-1, O-1, E, TN, P, R and other worker classifications filed by the employer.

Question 2

Same employer, same worker, same classification as the approved petition?

In other words, an extension of previously approved employment.

Question 3

Are the underlying facts the same?

Same job, same terms, no material change since the approval.

If no to question 1

Not covered. The deference regulation applies only to Form I-129. Other filings, such as a dependent’s Form I-539, are decided under their own rules.

If no to question 2

Deference generally doesn’t apply today. New employment, a change of employer and new concurrent employment are reviewed on their own. DHS’s data treats them as unaffected, so the proposal changes little for these filings.

If no to question 3

Little changes. A material change already lets the officer depart from the prior approval under today’s rule. Build full evidence of eligibility for the changed facts either way.

If yes to all three

This is the filing the proposal targets. Today, the officer should defer unless there was a material error, a material change or new material information, and must explain any departure. If the rule becomes final, the officer would review your evidence fresh and could still consider, but not presume, the earlier approval.

How should employers prepare I-129 extensions now?

Deference still applies until a final rule takes effect. Building every extension as if it had to stand alone costs little today and protects the filing if the rule changes while it’s pending.

  1. Prove continued eligibility, not just the prior approval. Include current evidence for the job, the employer and the classification’s requirements, as if it were a first filing.
  2. Document maintained status. An extension of stay generally requires that the worker has kept status; include records that show it.
  3. Check for anything that could look like a change. Title, duties, worksite, pay or corporate structure changes can already defeat deference today.
  4. Leave time for an RFE. File as early as the classification allows. Our post on the premium processing rule under review covers faster-processing options and their limits.
  5. Budget for the other 2026 changes. For L-1 employers, the $4,500 fee on extensions applies separately from this proposal.

What happens next?

Comments are open through November 13, 2026, and DHS accepts them only through Regulations.gov, docket USCIS-2026-0529. DHS must review the comments before it can publish a final rule, and it hasn’t said when that might happen. The Office of Management and Budget didn’t designate the proposal a significant regulatory action, so it wasn’t reviewed there. If the rule becomes final, USCIS says it would update the Policy Manual guidance on deference to match.

For a wider view of 2026 changes affecting employers, see our October 2026 employer visa landscape.

Frequently asked questions

Is the USCIS deference policy gone now?

No. This is a proposed rule. Until DHS publishes a final rule, 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5) stays in effect, and officers should still defer to a prior approval involving the same parties and facts unless there was a material error, a material change or new material information. The comment period runs through November 13, 2026.

Which petitions does deference cover?

It covers Form I-129 filings involving the same petitioner, the same beneficiary and the same underlying facts, most often an employer extending a worker’s petition in the same classification. That includes H-1B, L-1, O-1, E, TN and other I-129 categories. New employment, a change of employer and new concurrent employment generally don’t get deference.

Would removing deference mean more denials?

DHS’s own analysis says no measurable change. Comparing 2013–2017 (deference on) with 2017–2021 (deference off), DHS found extension RFE rates rose about 2.9 points more than for other petitions, but it found no corresponding change in denial rates. Past patterns may not hold, and officer practice can shift.

Can an officer still consider my prior approval?

Yes. The proposal says officers would not be prohibited from considering a prior approval where relevant. What changes is the starting point: officers would no longer begin from a presumption that the earlier approval was correct, and the petitioner would carry the full burden of proving continued eligibility.

What should employers do now?

Treat each extension as if it were a first filing. Include fresh evidence of the job, the employer and the worker’s maintained status, and don’t rely on a reference to the earlier approval. File early enough to absorb an RFE, and consider premium processing where it is available for the classification.

Planning an extension in 2027?

We build I-129 extensions that stand on their own evidence, so a change in review standards doesn’t catch your team off guard.

Start your free evaluation

Sources

  1. DHS notice of proposed rulemaking, Removing Deference to Prior USCIS Determinations of Eligibility, 91 FR 65119 (Oct. 14, 2026)
  2. Proposed rule, official PDF (GovInfo), FR Doc. 2026-20941
  3. 8 CFR 214.1, Requirements for admission, extension, and maintenance of status (eCFR)
  4. USCIS Policy Manual, Vol. 2, Part A, Ch. 4, Extension of Stay, Change of Status, and Extension of Petition Validity
  5. Regulations.gov docket USCIS-2026-0529

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Immigration law changes often and every case depends on its facts. Speak with a licensed immigration attorney about your situation. This summary reflects the proposed rule as published and is current as of November 11, 2026. Attorney Advertising.

01

Related Visa Category

02

Related Articles

03

More Articles

Need help with your immigration case?

Speak with our team about your options and the right next steps for your situation.

Book a ConsultationContact Us

← Back to all articles

Need help with your immigration case?

Hasan Legal PC attorneys handle USCIS petitions, family immigration, employment-based green cards, and naturalization across Washington DC, Virginia and Maryland.

Book a Consultation Free Evaluation
For informational purposes only — not legal advice · Consult an attorney for your specific situation.